Collagen Hydrogel Scaffold and Fibroblast Growth Factor-2 Accelerate Periodontal Healing of Class II Furcation Defects in Dog
Takehito Momose, Hirofumi Miyaji*, Akihito Kato, Kosuke Ogawa, Takashi Yoshida, Erika Nishida, Syusuke Murakami, Yuta Kosen, Tsutomu Sugaya, Masamitsu Kawanami
Identifiers and Pagination:Year: 2016
First Page: 347
Last Page: 359
Publisher Id: TODENTJ-10-347
Article History:Received Date: 26/11/2015
Revision Received Date: 13/6/2016
Acceptance Date: 21/6/2016
Electronic publication date: 29/07/2016
Collection year: 2016
open-access license: This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial 4.0 International Public License (CC BY-NC 4.0) (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/legalcode), which permits unrestricted, non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
Collagen hydrogel scaffold exhibits bio-safe properties and facilitates periodontal wound healing. However, regenerated tissue volume is insufficient. Fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF2) up-regulates cell behaviors and subsequent wound healing. We evaluated whether periodontal wound healing is promoted by application of collagen hydrogel scaffold in combination with FGF2 in furcation defects in beagle dogs.
Collagen hydrogel was fabricated from bovine type I collagen with an ascorbate-copper ion cross-linking system. Collagen hydrogel was mingled with FGF2 and injected into sponge-form collagen. Subsequently, FGF2 (50 µg)/collagen hydrogel scaffold and collagen hydrogel scaffold alone were implanted into class II furcation defects in dogs. In addition, no implantation was performed as a control. Histometric parameters were assessed at 10 days and 4 weeks after surgery.
FGF2 application to scaffold promoted considerable cell and tissue ingrowth containing numerous cells and blood vessel-like structure at day 10. At 4 weeks, reconstruction of alveolar bone was stimulated by implantation of scaffold loaded with FGF2. Furthermore, periodontal attachment, consisting of cementum-like tissue, periodontal ligament-like tissue and Sharpey’s fibers, was also repaired, indicating that FGF2-loaded scaffold guided self-assembly and then re-established the function of periodontal organs. Aberrant healing, such as ankylosis and root resorption, was not observed.
FGF2-loaded collagen hydrogel scaffold possessed excellent biocompatibility and strongly promoted periodontal tissue engineering, including periodontal attachment re-organization.
In tissue engineering strategies for periodontitis, cellular proliferation and differentiation should be facilitated in order to regenerate alveolar bone and functional periodontal attachment [1-3]. Scaffold implantation therapy plays a significant role in repopulation and differentiation of stem cells and extracellular matrices when periodontal surgery is performed, resulting in a periodontal regenerative effect. Hydrogels generally consist of synthetic and naturally hydrated polymers, and exhibit physical and biological properties . A range of hydrogel scaffolds, such as alginate , hyaluronic acid , chitosan , collagen  and gelatin  have been used in recent studies. After implantation of these substrates into the body, good tissue compatibility and degradability were frequently shown. Hydrogel scaffolds show promise for use in periodontal tissue engineering.
Recently, type I collagen hydrogel was prepared by an ascorbate-copper ion system  and its bio-safety was confirmed in animals . In particular, cell ingrowth and subsequent self-assembly organization were frequently demonstrated on collagen hydrogel application. Kosen et al.  and Kato et al.  revealed that implantation of a three-dimensional scaffold, composed of collagen hydrogel and sponge form, facilitated periodontal healing, including reconstruction of the periodontal attachment apparatus. Consistently, periodontal adverse effects, namely, root resorption and ankylosis, were not observed with collagen hydrogel therapy. However, the volume of regenerative periodontal tissue was about half of the experimental defect. Thus, a combinatorial approach for tissue engineering is needed to stimulate periodontal reconstruction.
Collagen hydrogels reportedly possess water absorption properties ; therefore, collagen hydrogel scaffolds may serve as a carrier of aqueous signaling molecules. Fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF2) stimulates proliferation of vascular endothelial cells  and fibroblasts , promoting wound healing . In addition, FGF2 positively modulates osteoblast differentiation , bone formation  and periodontal healing [19, 20]. Thus, we hypothesized that a combination of FGF2 and collagen hydrogel scaffold dramatically improved the biological effects for periodontal tissue engineering. Accordingly, we investigated whether FGF2-loaded collagen hydrogel scaffold promoted periodontal tissue healing. Scaffolds were implanted into dog class II furcation defects as preclinical tests to assess the biological effects of collagen hydrogel and FGF-2 application.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
FGF2 Implant Preparation and Morphological Analysis
Collagen hydrogel with a concentration of 1.5% (Fig. 1A) was fabricated using atelocollagen powder from calf skin (Koken, Tokyo, Japan), as described previously . Atelocollagen was dissolved in 1 M HCl, and was stirred for 3 days. Subsequently, crosslinking was performed by adding 1 mM L(+)-ascorbic acid and 0.1 mM CuCl2. Next, the collagen hydrogel (100 µl) was injected into a sponge form of collagen (5 × 3 × 3 mm, porosity of 97%; Terudermis®; Olympus Terumo Biomaterials, Tokyo, Japan; (Fig. 1B) under vacuum.
Some scaffolds received FGF2 (50 µg, Fiblast spray 500; Kaken Pharmaceutical, Tokyo, Japan), as described previously . FGF2 was added to collagen hydrogel (100 µl), and the collagen sponge was then infused with the admixture (Fig. 1C). To observe the morphology of hydrogel penetration, sponges injected with collagen hydrogel were embedded in paraffin wax in accordance with conventional methods, then cut into 6-µm sections. Sections were stained with hematoxylin-eosin (HE), and were observed using light microscopy.
The Animal Research Committee of Hokkaido University approved the experimental protocols (approval number: 8-255). Six female beagle dogs, aged approximately 14 months and weighing approximately 10 kg, received intramuscular anesthesia with medetomidine hydrochloride (0.1 ml/kg, Domitor; Nippon Zenyaku Kogyo, Koriyama, Japan) and butorphanol tartrate (0.1 ml/kg, Vetorphale; Meiji Seika, Tokyo, Japan). Local anesthesia was induced with lidocaine hydrochloride (2% with 1:80,000 epinephrine, Xylocaine; Dentsply-sankin, Tokyo, Japan).
After reflecting the buccal partial-thickness flap, soft tissue including periosteum was scraped from alveolar bone. The creation of artificial buccal class II furcation defects (5 mm in height, 3 mm horizontally) was carried out on the mandibular second, third and fourth premolars (Fig. 2A). After removing cementum using a scaler, bone defect notches were fabricated and the root surface was treated with EDTA (24%, pH 7.0) to remove debris. Thirty-six defects were randomly divided into the three groups. Subsequently, defects were filled with FGF2-loaded or unloaded scaffolds (Fig. 2B) and the repositioned flap was sutured (Fig. 2C). No implantation was performed in the control group. All dogs received postoperative treatment with ampicillin sodium (300 mg/kg, Viccillin; Meiji Seika, Tokyo, Japan) administration for 3 days and plaque control with chlorhexidine (0.5%, Hibitane; Sumitomo Dainippon Pharma, Tokyo, Japan) twice weekly.
(A) Class II furcation periodontal defects (5 mm in height, 3 mm horizontally). (B) Implantation of scaffold. (C) Post-surgery. (Scale bars represent 5 mm).
Animals were euthanized with sodium pentobarbital (0.5 ml/kg, Somnopentyl; Kyoritsu, Tokyo, Japan). Tissue blocks, including teeth, bone and soft tissue were collected from the wound at 10 days (N=3) and 4 weeks (N=9) after surgery. Following fixation in 10% buffered formalin and decalcification in 10% formic acid, specimens were embedded in paraffin wax in accordance with conventional methods. We then prepared serial 6-μm sections along the mesio-distal plane and applied HE and Masson’s trichrome staining.
Histomorphometric measurements of 4-week samples, including area of defect and bone, and length of defect, periodontal ligament-like tissue, cementum-like tissue and epithelial tissue, and exposed root surface (Fig. 3), were performed on five stained sections; center and every 120 µm in the buccal direction, using a software package (Image J 1.41, National Institute of Health, Bethesda, MD).
Sections were also evaluated in order to determine the composition of cementum-like tissue (cellular/acellular) and the density of periodontal ligament-like tissue (0 = no fibrous connective tissue; 1 = low-density fibrous connective tissue layer; 2 = high-density fibrous connective tissue layer), using a modified method from the protocol described by Kim et al. .
HE-stained collagen hydrogel scaffold sections are shown in Fig. (1D). Collagen hydrogel was found to penetrate into the sponge form as an amorphous structure.
Clinical Observations of Periodontal Healing
The postoperative healing process appeared to be favorable in all dogs. At 4 weeks, macroscopic findings showed evidence of gingival recession in the control group. FGF2 increased radiopacity in the bone defect (Fig. 4).
Histological Observations at 10 Days
In control specimens, marked formation of inflammatory granulation tissue was noted in the defect. Furcation fornix was frequently exposed to the mouth and infected by dental plaque accumulation. Alveolar bone and periodontal attachment formation was rarely demonstrated. Epithelial tissue was particularly detected in the coronal portion of the defect (Fig. 5).
In the hydrogel scaffold-treated group at 10 days, the scaffold remained in the furcation defect and cell-rich tissue containing numerous cells and blood vessel-like structures apparently infiltrated into the scaffold. Some alveolar bone formed close to pre-existing bone in the apical portion of the defect. Epithelial tissue invasion was not observed in specimens at either the center or buccal sites (Fig. 6).
The FGF2-treated group clearly showed ingrowth of numerous cells and vessel-like structures in the scaffold. In particular, formation of woven bone was promoted when compared with the control and collagen hydrogel-treated groups. Alveolar bone was continuous with apical pre-existing bone and included many osteoblastic cells. Blood vessel-like tissue formation frequently occurred when compared with the control and scaffold alone groups. Although new periodontal attachment was not observed on the root surface, fibrous tissue was accumulated on the root surface. In addition, epithelial tissue infiltration was inhibited, thus suggesting that collagen hydrogel implantation would maintain the regenerative space (Fig. 7).
Histological Observations at 4 Weeks
In control specimens, connective tissue was mainly formed in the defect. Repair of alveolar bone and periodontal attachment were limited to the root surface. Cementum-like tissue and periodontal ligament-like tissue were not observed on the coronal root surface (Fig. 8).
In the scaffold-treated group, new bone was generated, in contrast to the control group, and occupied about half the area of the furcation defect. Periodontal attachment continuous with the original periodontal organs, including fiber structures resembling Sharpey’s fibers, was reformed on the instrumented root surface. The interspace for periodontal ligament showed rich extracellular matrix and stained perpendicular fibers. Down-growth of the epithelial tissue was rarely noted. In addition, ankylosis and root resorption were not evident (Fig. 9).
FGF2 application strongly promoted periodontal healing. The furcation defect was mostly occupied by newly formed bone. Serial sections showed that alveolar bone was formed at the buccal area of the furcation defect. Periodontal attachment apparatus was clearly observed at every part of furcation. Sharpey’s fibers were well-developed at the interface of periodontal ligament-like tissue, indicating that the re-establishment of functionally periodontal attachment was stimulated. Scaffold loaded with FGF2 suppressed epithelial down-growth and did not induce aberrant healing, such as ankylosis and root resorption (Fig. 10).
The degree of periodontal healing is shown in Fig. (11). The FGF2-loaded group showed the most active bone and periodontal attachment forming effects among the three groups. The mean value of new bone area of the FGF2 receiving group was approximately 2-fold greater than in the control group. In addition, reforming of periodontal ligament-like tissue and cementum-like tissue was significantly stimulated by FGF2 application. Down-growth of epithelial tissue was observed in all furcation defects in the control group, but was rarely seen in the hydrogel scaffold-treated and FGF2-treated groups. Therefore, collagen hydrogel scaffold prevented epithelial tissue invasion. At 4 weeks, the collagen scaffold was completely degraded in all groups. Implanted substrate was considered to be quickly replaced by regenerative tissue.
In addition, two sections (the central plane and 480 µm away from the central plane) were selected for histometric assessment (Fig. 12). In the buccal section, bone, periodontal ligament-like tissue and cementum-like tissue were reformed in all groups, and these parameters were consistently decreased when compared with the central section. Periodontal tissue reformation in the mid-section was thought to be facilitated by the positive effects of residual lingual wall in the furcation defects. However, implantation of FGF2-loaded scaffold resulted in 70% of periodontal tissue reconstruction, even in the buccal section. In contrast, the buccal section in the control group frequently showed down-growth of epithelial tissue.
The frequency of the composition of cementum-like tissue and density of periodontal ligament-like tissue are shown in Table 1. Cementum-like tissue frequently appeared to be acellular cementum and received Sharpey’s fiber insertions. Reformed periodontal ligament-like tissue exhibited fiber-rich connective tissue layer after trichrome staining. In particular, periodontal ligament-like tissue was well-developed in the FGF2-treated group.
Frequency of histological observations at 4 weeks after surgery (N = 9, mean ± standard deviation).
|Composition of cementum-like tissue||Acellular||15.3±4.7||26.7±6.2||47.6±11.6|
|Density of periodontal ligament-like tissue||1.2 ± 0.4||1.6 ± 0.5||1.9 ± 0.3|
On histological observation at 10 days, cell ingrowth into the scaffold was frequently detected after implantation of collagen hydrogel scaffold. Further addition of FGF2 strongly promoted cell and tissue ingrowth and subsequent bone formation. Therefore, the combination of FGF2 and collagen hydrogel scaffold intensely enhanced bioactivities for periodontal wound healing. It has been reported that fibroblast proliferation and migration associated with the wound healing process is up-regulated by FGF2 application [23, 24]. Furthermore, FGF2 facilitated the healing of osseous tissue including the osteoblast proliferative process and bone repair [17, 25]. Collagen hydrogel is able to absorb and retain significant amounts of water ; therefore, FGF2 in aqueous solution would be possessed by collagen hydrogel and released via diffusion and scaffold degradation, resulting in bio-effects of FGF2 in periodontal cells and tissues. On the other hand, collagen hydrogel was composed of type I collagen, which is available for the reconstruction of extracellular matrix and connective tissue. Numerous investigators have discussed the potential of type I collagen in cell proliferation and participation in tissue repair [26, 27]. In the present study, ingrowth of periodontal cells was also observed at an early stage with single use of collagen hydrogel, similarly to previous in vivo studies using collagen hydrogel . Thus, FGF2 and collagen hydrogel show promise as new periodontal therapeutic approaches in bio-effective tissue engineering.
Four-week specimens of the FGF2-treated group showed that formation of alveolar bone in furcation defects was consistently advanced when compared with other groups. In the 10-day specimens, alveolar bone formation was observed when compared with the control and scaffold alone groups. These results suggest that early bone induction and remodeling are promoted by FGF2 effects. It was reported that FGF2 increased proliferation of vascular endothelial cells and rebuilding of the blood vessel network . In addition, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) was secreted from periodontal ligament cells on FGF2 stimulation . Early ingrowth of blood vessel-like structures was frequently observed in the scaffold containing FGF2 when compared with the group lacking FGF2. We speculated that the FGF2 effect on blood vessel formation would up-regulate bone tissue remodeling. In general, vascularization played a significant role in providing nutrition factors for wound healing and tissue remodeling . Further, mesenchymal stem cells accumulated in the wound via blood vessels in tissue regeneration. Accordingly, supply of vascular elements would be advantageous for bone tissue engineering. Fujimura et al. revealed that higher oxygen partial pressure could enhance bone regeneration . Therefore, construction of the neovascular network at the FGF2 implantation site would enhance cell differentiation of osteoblasts, resulting in new bone induction.
It is very important in periodontal tissue engineering to reproduce the periodontal attachment apparatus and alveolar bone simultaneously. In this experiment, periodontal attachment including periodontal ligament-like tissue and cementum-like tissue was well-formed by implantation of FGF2-loaded scaffold. Although alveolar bone was formed in the furcation defect, there was no ankylotic union on the treated root surface. A previous study reported that the use of FGF2 promoted the growth of periodontal stem cells in vitro . It seems likely that proliferation of periodontal stem cells was promoted by FGF2, and then reconstruction of periodontal attachment was selectively guided along the root surface by interaction between the extracellular matrix and dentin. With regard to FGF2 application, ankylosis was rarely seen in an animal study on periodontal tissue engineering [19, 20]. In contrast, osteogenic growth factor, or bone morphogenetic protein, could be applied for alveolar bone formation [33-35]; however, they frequently resulted in ankylosis or poor organized periodontal ligament . The self-assembling effect of FGF2 would be highly advantageous for periodontal tissue engineering. On the other hand, Kosen et al.  demonstrated that hydrogel scaffold prevented epithelial invasion in dog furcation defects. We also noted similar observations in the present examination. The rate of epithelial down-growth in the hydrogel scaffold-treated group was less than in controls, regardless of FGF2 loading. The collagen hydrogel scaffold likely forms a fibrous barrier against epithelial down-growth and results in predictable periodontal healing.
Collagen hydrogel exhibited high fluidity; however, the combination with collagen sponge form could hold large amounts of hydrogel in the periodontal defect. In addition, severe inflammation was rarely seen following implantation of the collagen scaffold. Normally, collagen substrate should undergo crosslinking to improve its mechanical strength. In this study, we selected a bio-safe system using the ascorbate-copper ion reaction as the hydrogel cross-linking method , thus ensuring that the gel form collagen maintained good biocompatibility. Furthermore, the collagen sponge consisted of bio-suitable atelocollagen and is widely applied as artificial skin [37, 38]. Low degradable biomaterial remains in periodontal tissue long-term after surgery, increasing the risk of infection or prevention of repair . Histological specimens showed that collagen implants were mostly degraded at 4 weeks post-surgery. Interestingly, Matsui et al.  reported that bovine collagen composed of collagen sponge was degraded and then reused for dermal tissue formation in a rat subcutaneous tissue test. Accordingly, collagen scaffold may supply the forming material for reconstruction of periodontal tissue composed chiefly of collagen. This is a significant point for periodontal tissue engineering, but further studies are needed to clarify these biological effects.
We evaluated the effects of collagen hydrogel scaffold in combination with FGF2 on periodontal wound healing using a class II furcation defect model. The results showed that healing of alveolar bone and periodontal attachment was strongly promoted by scaffold implantation. In addition, FGF2-loaded hydrogel scaffold consistently suppressed aberrant healing, such as epithelial down-growth, ankylosis and root resorption. The FGF2-loaded scaffold was bioeffective in periodontal tissue engineering.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors confirm that this article content has no conflict of interest.
We would like to thank Olympus Terumo Biomaterials Corp. for providing the Terudermis. This work was supported by JPSP KAKENHI Grant Number 22791916 and 25463210. The authors report no conflicts of interest related to this study.